What’s Stopping SME Exports?
Tuesday, July 20th, 2010Wow! I’m impressed. Government studies often help me to take a nap, but here is one that has some eye-popping stuff in it. The U.S. International Trade Commission has released the second in its series of studies about exporting by U.S. Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs). I know, that sounds like a snoozer, but bear with me. The first ITC report, released in January and reported upon here, was a scene-setter that examined the scope and role of SME exporting in the context of overall U.S. exports. The major conclusion was that most SMEs sell to only one foreign customer in one foreign market, usually Canada, so there is beaucoup room for improvement.
The new report looks at specific issues faced by SMEs and compares U.S. programs and conditions with those our European Union competitors use to help their small companies. There is so much meat in the report that the executive summary takes up a full eight pages. I’ll attempt to hit the major points here, but I suspect I will draw on the ITC report for several more posts in coming weeks.
The ITC begins by disposing of a semi-myth, that SMEs are far more prominent in the European Union’s exports than in those of the United States. That’s true, as far as it goes. Using 2005 data, the latest comparable, SMEs sold 31% of the EU’s manufactured exports but only 13% of America’s foreign sales. They say not to make too big an issue of this, however, because the U.S. market is so large and well integrated that America has tended to grow more big companies than has the EU, thus it is no surprise that big companies dominate our exports. I agree with the impact of a large integrated economy, but I know from personal experience that the Eurocrats have being doing everything possible to grow Europe’s SMEs into something larger. Both in meetings in Brussels and at a conference about SMEs in Copenhagen, Eurocrats made it clear to me that, in their opinion, being small is a disease and that Brussels has the doctors to cure it.
I was surprised to see the ITC’s conclusion that U.S. financing for SME exports is no worse than in Europe, given the moaning I hear from small U.S. companies. In fact, U.S. pre-export and short-term credit appears superior to what the Europeans are doing for their firms. European exporters, however, may have better access to help in foreign markets – and far better support for participation in international trade shows. (I have seen EU exporters laugh out loud when they hear how little official assistance is available to Americans at trade shows.) The ITC also notes that European countries attact foreign investors with a view to building new export industries, something the U.S. Government cannot do because investment promotion is largely the preserve of individual states and cities.
There is a major difference in the structure of U.S. and European SME exports. In Europe most SMEs do their own exporting, while American SMEs tend to sell their product to middlemen who then do the exporting. I interpret this as part of our firms’ absorption in the huge North American market, though I suspect it also reveals a lack of willingness to take on the perceived risks of exporting. If you can sell most or all of your product in a market you thoroughly understand, then you are less likely to take on markets you don’t know. That’s understandable, if perhaps short-sighted.
The ITC then looks at barriers to exporting. Most SMEs, anywhere, have difficulties with obtaining good and sufficient financing. Their size makes them appear higher risk to the banks, and a focus on foreign markets makes them seem even riskier to the green eye-shade people.
The U.S. Government sets up its own barriers to SME exporting. Export controls are front and center due to their complexity and immense paperwork. Visa issues are equally important, hindering efforts to bring potential buyers to the United States for contract talks or for training, and for stopping immigration of specialized foreign workers that a company might need. SMEs also complained to the ITC about poor coordination among government agencies and unnecessary tariffs on inputs they need for production. I wrote about the latter last week before beginning to read the new ITC report.
Transport costs are a big issue, especially the relative lack of availability of containers on the West Coast. Foreign regulations are a huge hindrance for a small company that lacks the staff to fully understand and ensure compliance in multiple markets. IPR protection is a big concern, especially for those SMEs trying to do business in China. Ditto delays at foreign ports for perishable products, such as foodstuffs or pharmaceuticals. Increasingly U.S. SMEs see “unfair” competition from foreign competitors who benefit from free trade agreements their governments have negotiated, while the United States remains inactive in FTA negotiations (is anybody in the Democratic leadership listening?). Language and cultural issues, and limited knowledge of foreign markets, are yet more consequences of our over-reliance on our huge domestic market.
What do American SMEs do to overcome these reasons not to export, and what does the ITC recommend? Check in again tomorrow.
***************************
Oh, Sunday was fun! We had an outrigger paddling regatta at Waikiki, right in front of the Outrigger, the Moana and the Royal Hawaiian. What a setting! And the waves were great, though boats were swamped or flipped in most every race. My first race was the men’s 60s. We powered our way out through the surf, taking big hits from the waves but surviving. We made perhaps our best turn of the season at the quarter-mile mark, then accelerated back to the finish line at the beach, riding the surf much of the way. There is an art to riding waves and breaking surf. The acceleration is exhilarating and a good crew can stay on a wave for a long ride. We were good Sunday and finished a strong second.
My second race, the mixed 55s, was even more exciting. We never even made it to the turn. I was stroking (that’s the first seat, the paddler who sets the pace), and we got hit three times in succession by big waves. We kept going and were moving fairly well, though the boat was full of water. Then I saw the monster. Had to be twice the size of the others. I shouted to apply all the power we had, but it was no good. I was knocked into the lap of the second paddler (a rather petite woman) and then, in an instant, our canoe was upside down. Our race was over and our focus turned instantly to making sure everybody was safe and unhurt. Jetskis got us safely back to the beach and towed the boat in. Our coach, standing on the beach, told me he saw that fourth wave and knew we didn’t have a chance. Exciting!









